The Secure Act killed the stretch IRA — here are alternatives for your inheritance

Individual retirement account holders may have been quite surprised — perhaps unpleasantly — when new retirement legislation killed their attempt at a tax-advantageous inheritance for their loved ones. The Secure Act, an expansive retirement law that went into effect Jan. 1, eliminated the “stretch IRA,” which allowed non-spousal beneficiaries to withdraw assets of inherited accounts over their lifetimes. Now, those who inherited an IRA since the beginning of 2020 and thereafter have 10 years to withdraw the assets — however or whenever they’d like — or face taxation of the money all at once. Spouses and disabled beneficiaries are among the exceptions to the rule. The new restrictions pose a problem for people who have been planning to use IRAs as an inheritance vehicle, but the strategy was never one Congress intended to offer. “The Stretch IRA was a loophole,” said Ric Edelman, co-founder of Edelman Financial Engines. “IRAs are designed to be lifetime income for you.” Still, with the loss of this method, IRA holders may need a new plan. Keeping these accounts as an inheritance for a non-spouse is still an option, but doing so could put adult children and other beneficiaries in a predicament, especially if they are near or in their peak earning years when they come into the money. Withdrawals of inherited IRAs are taxed at the beneficiary’s ordinary income tax-rate, which means a high earner would be paying more on their newfound assets than if they received the inheritance in another form.

The Secure Act changed the way some family members may leave their loved ones with an inheritance.

Edelman suggested account holders spend down their own IRAs and use other viable options for a wealth transfer. Here are a few alternatives to the stretch IRA:

Taxable investment accounts

Some experts also say bullion could help investors if there is a financial crisis and deflation. When a financial crisis hits, central banks may have no choice but to lower the cost of borrowing far below zero, says Don Coxe, chairman of Chicago-based Coxe Advisors. That will make gold bullion even more attractive relative to negative-yielding bonds because of its long history of maintaining its purchasing power. The downside of bullion is that it never pays a dividend, and there are generally charges for insurance and storage in vaults, which can bite into profits. ETFs have helped reduced that burden, making small investments viable. “The storage costs have been mitigated by ETFs, which somewhat distribute the cost among the investor pool,” Mr. Savant says. There are plenty of bullion ETFs from which to choose, including SPDR Gold Shares (GLD), the largest, with more than $45 billion in assets. Others include GraniteShares Gold Trust (BAR) and VanEck Merk Gold Trust (OUNZ).

Beneficiaries typically don’t pay capital gains on inherited investment accounts, which make them an attractive option for an inheritance, Edelman said. Inheritors would only have to pay taxes if they sell the investments after the account was transferred, according to Vanguard. There are ways to minimize that tax bill. The cost basis is the amount the account holder paid for the investments — the “stepped-up” part of the name refers to the asset being adjusted to its fair market value at the time of the inheritance, Vanguard said. If the value of the assets were worth more at the time of the account holder’s death than when he or she initially paid for them, the inheritor can avoid or lessen their tax burden.

A life insurance policy can be a major perk for individuals and their heirs. “Parents can spend all of their assets and the kids still get an inheritance,” Edelman said. In some cases — they may even get more than they would have had they inherited an IRA, said James Gambaccini, a financial adviser and managing partner at Acorn Financial Services in Reston, Va. Traditional IRA holders can begin taking withdrawals from their accounts to buy life insurance to benefit inheritors, said Brandon Opre, a financial adviser and founder of TrustTree Financial in Huntersville, N.C. “This may allow for not only a tax-free death benefit to be passed down, but the policy could potentially build up cash values to benefit their heirs over time.” People interested in this strategy should consider doing so when they’re younger. Account owners can begin taking withdrawals from their IRAs without a penalty beginning at 59½ years old, said Catherine Valega, a financial adviser at Green Bee Advisory in Waltham, Mass. If they plan to use a life insurance policy, they should speak with an estate planner to make sure this is a right step for them, and then meet with a life insurance agent, who can run a quote based on their health.

Get life insurance

Individuals planning to leave money to charities may want to consider giving those institutions their IRAs because the charities will not have to pay taxes, said David Haas, a financial adviser and owner of Cereus Financial Advisors in Franklin Lakes, N.J. Account owners can also name a Charitable Remainder Trust as a beneficiary of an IRA, he said. Beneficiaries would get a lifetime stretch, with the remaining balance going to a designated charity, but the downside is they don’t have access to the money freely, in the case of an emergency. “I recommend using an experienced estate attorney for anyone interested in this technique,” Haas said. Another option for those with charities as beneficiaries: Qualified Charitable Distributions from IRAs, for people who are 70½ and older. These vehicles draw down IRA assets, and the distributions count toward required minimum distributions, which eliminates future taxable distributions, said Rob Greenman, a financial adviser and partner of Vista Capital Partners in Portland, Ore.

Leave the IRA to a charity

Traditional IRAs, which are funded with pre-tax dollars, can be converted into Roth IRAs, which house after-tax contributions. From an income tax perspective, this could be an option for those looking to leave their money with an inheritance, but not a hefty tax bill. This strategy is best for heirs who are in a tax bracket at least as high as the original account owner. “Chipping away at the future tax liability due on withdrawals at low income bracket levels over a number of years could be a favorable move,” Greenman said.

Roth conversions

Taking a long-term look at tech investing | Kim Lew, Carnegie Corp. CIO, says long-term investors should have the ability to predict the impact of technology.

Preview

You may not collect a paycheck anymore, but you could still owe taxes on the money you earn in retirement. Here's what you might have to pay on 10 sources of income.

How your retirement income gets taxed

Hover for preview

The 20 stocks on this list appear to have safe dividends, yield between 3.5% and 6.9%, and have solid potential to continue growing their payouts in the long term.

20 stocks to boost your retirement income

Hover for preview

A financially secure retirement won't just happen to you. Craft a carefully considered plan and stick to it. Read this news feed and more on retirement issues.

8 retirement investing mistakes to avoid

Hover for preview

Tech impact

Video

Retirement taxes

Article

Income investing

MultiMedia

Retirement planning

News Feed

Extra //