New research shows what earns small business shoppers’ confidence, what puts it at risk and how unexpected events can impact loyalty
Loyalty can be tested
would temporarily shop with a competitor if a small business closed due to an unexpected event.
Trust can be lost quickly
ranked product safety issues and customer data/privacy breaches as the top factors that would damage their trust in a small business.
Key findings
Employee safety strengthens reliability
say businesses that invest in employee safety are more likely to provide reliable service and remain successful over time.
54% — Treating employees fairly
54% — Transparent communication when problems occur
62% — Protecting customer data
68% — Reliable products and services
Reliable service earns customer trust
When asked to rank the factors that were most important in earning trust, respondents most often placed the following among their top three:
Trust can be lost quickly
Trust is shaped by more than products and services. Respondents ranked product safety, data protection and employee treatment among the top concerns that would likely impact trust in a small business.
Why it matters
This shows small business shoppers' trust depends on more than the quality of a business's products or services. Respondents indicated they are highly sensitive to product safety issues, data breaches and employee treatment. For small business owners, protecting customers, data and employees is essential to maintaining customer trust and long-term loyalty.
A proactive risk management program can help a business identify concerns earlier, reduce the chance of a loss and prepare employees to respond if something goes wrong.
Questions for small business owners to consider:
Are quality controls and a product recall plan in place?
Are employees trained to protect customer data and respond to cyber threats?
Is there a regular review of workplace safety, injury-reporting and return-to-work procedures?
Employee safety strengthens reliability
Business continuity also depends on having a supported workforce. Respondents associated employee safety with reliable service and long-term business success. A well-managed workplace can help keep employees on the job, provide consistent service and show customers that the business cares for its employees.
Why it matters
For business owners, regular training, clear reporting procedures and return-to-work planning can support employees while strengthening operational continuity.
Questions for small business owners to consider:
Are workplace safety programs reviewed regularly?
Do employees receive ongoing safety training?
Is there a process for reporting injuries and workplace hazards?
Is there a return-to-work process for injured employees?
Is risk management support available through the insurance program?
Why work with an independent agent?
Choosing the right coverage starts with understanding the business. An independent agent can help identify potential coverage gaps, explore available options and build an insurance program that reflects the needs of the business.
Small businesses that proactively manage risk can strengthen customer confidence and position themselves to recover more effectively when disruptions occur. Independent agents can help them navigate evolving risks and prepare for the unexpected.
— Charles (Chip) F. Hamann
President, Small Commercial, The Hanover
About The Hanover
Together with its independent agent partners, The Hanover offers standard and specialized insurance protection for small and mid-sized businesses, as well as for homes, automobiles and other personal items. For more information, visit hanover.com.
Survey method
The online survey was conducted by Statista+ on behalf of The Hanover from Sept. 2–4, 2026, among 500 U.S. consumers ages 18 to 64 who purchase products or services from small businesses at least once a month. For ranking questions, “top three” represents the percentage placing an item first, second or third.
For complete survey methodology, including weighting variables and subgroup sample sizes, please contact aursoleo@hanover.com.
Press contacts
Abby C. Ursoleo
aursoleo@hanover.com
508-855-3549
Emily P. Trevallion
etrevallion@hanover.com
508-855-3263
Small businesses play an important role in their communities, but the trust they have earned can be tested when operations are disrupted, customer information is compromised or employees are put at risk. New research from The Hanover and Statista examines the factors that most influence customer trust and the events most likely to damage a business's reputation. The research surveyed small business shoppers and the findings underscore the role preparedness, employee safety and risk management play in helping small businesses maintain trust.
said a serious product safety issue would damage their trust
of small business shoppers say small businesses are extremely or very important to their communities.
reported a customer data/privacy breach would damage their trust
said evidence of employee mistreatment or injury would damage their trust
A temporary closure can test customer loyalty
Beyond affecting trust, an unexpected event can also change where customers choose to shop. According to the survey, 61% of respondents shop at a small business at least once a week. When the business has to close temporarily, customers may be understanding, but most will still look elsewhere to meet an immediate need. The survey found:
Why it matters
Most consumers won’t wait long to temporarily shop with a competitor.
For small business owners, the message is clear: having a plan to keep operating during disruptions, or to recover quickly when they occur, can help protect both revenue and customer loyalty.
Questions for small business owners to consider:
Is there a documented business continuity plan?
Could the business continue operating during a prolonged shutdown?
Have critical suppliers and backup options been identified?
Has business income insurance coverage been reviewed recently?
Are business continuity planning resources available through the insurance program?
54% would wait less than one week before seeking alternatives
60% would shop with a competitor temporarily
agree that a small business that invests in employee safety is more likely to provide reliable service and remain successful over time
The difference the right insurance carrier can make
A trusted carrier partner provides more than coverage. Responsive claims service, proactive risk management guidance and strong business continuity planning resources can help small businesses prepare for disruptions, respond when losses occur and work toward reopening as quickly as possible.
3.
2.
1.
Strengthen employee safety. Review workplace safety programs, provide ongoing training and establish injury-reporting and return-to-work processes.
Protect customer data and privacy. Train employees, keep secure backups and have a response plan ready before a cyber incident occurs.
Prepare for the unexpected. Maintain a continuity plan, identify backup suppliers and regularly review business income coverage.
Three ways to build a more resilient business
The survey results offer small business owners a clear place to focus. By taking action in three key areas, businesses can help protect their operations, employees and customer relationships.
All products are underwritten by The Hanover Insurance Company or one of its insurance company subsidiaries or affiliates (“The Hanover”). Coverage may not be available in all jurisdictions and is subject to the company underwriting guidelines and the issued policy. This material is provided for informational purposes only and does not provide any coverage or guarantee loss prevention. For more information visit www.hanover.com.
Insurance programs that offer value-added services and resources in these key areas can provide more than just protection. They help small businesses build resilience, navigate challenges and keep operations moving forward when unexpected events occur.